Prisoners' rights
All Updates
Fernandez Iradi v. France, no. 23421/21
Prison authorities’ failure to provide access to medical care for a prisoner suffering from multiple sclerosis after domestic court had decided that such medical care was necessary to render the applicant’s continued detention compatible with his state of health.
Judgment
Rasmussen and Others v. Denmark, no. 2390/24
Accidental death of a prisoner caused by a drug overdose.
Judgment
Văscăuţanu v. Romania (dec.), no. 10120/23
Complaint about continuous inhuman and degrading treatment in prison caused by material conditions of detention.
Decision | Legal Summary
A.V. v. Switzerland, no. 37639/19
Systematic monitoring of the applicant’s correspondence in prison, with the exception of correspondence with her lawyer and several public institutions.
Judgment
Vainik and Others v. Estonia, nos. 17982/21 and 3 others
Total ban on smoking in prison, also for prisoners with a long-term smoking habit, such as the applicants.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Platon v. the Republic of Moldova, no. 74995/17
Allegedly insufficient medical assistance, and lack of an effective remedy, to a former member of a municipal council and of Parliament while in detention, and regular sanctions suspending family visits for over two years.
Judgment
Gullotti v. Italy, no. 64753/14
Limitation of the applicant’s right to correspondence during his detention under a special regime for imprisoned Mafia members.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Hayes v. the United Kingdom, nos. 56532/22 and 2 others
Complaint about impending extradition to the USA, which would, if the applicants were to be convicted, allegedly result in a mandatory sentence of life imprisonment without the possibility of parole if the applicant was to be convicted.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Uygun v. Türkiye, no. 9389/19
Prison authorities’ refusal to send the applicant’s letter to his fiancée, a paragraph having been interpreted as evidence of his ongoing involvement with a terrorist organisation.
Judgment
Kalkan v. Denmark, no. 51781/22
Death of the applicant’s son in prison after being restrained in a prone position leg lock for about thirteen minutes, following which he suffered a heart attack.
Judgment
Tergek v. Türkiye, no. 39631/20 (pending before the GC)
Refusal of prison authorities to hand over to a convicted prisoner voluminous internet printouts sent to him by his relatives by post.
Judgment
Morabito v. Italy, no. 4953/22
Continued placement of an elderly applicant, convicted of leadership of a Mafia-type criminal organisation, under a special restrictive prison regime, despite his progressive cognitive deterioration.
Judgment
Gözütok v. Türkiye (dec.), no. 41412/21
Conditions of the applicant’s detention in the quarantine ward and of his transfer to the hospital during the Covid-19 pandemic, and his medical examination whilst allegedly being handcuffed.
Decision
Adamčo v. Slovakia (no. 2), nos. 55792/20, 35253/21 and 41955/22
Thorough strip searches systematically carried out on a prisoner, regardless of other security arrangements in place.
Judgment
Ribár v. Slovakia, no. 56545/21
Conditions of detention pending trial (esp. twenty-three-hour confinement to the applicant’s cell), which lasted approximately one and a half years and which was ordered, inter alia, to prevent the applicant from interfering with the course of justice.
Judgment
Eldar Hasanov v. Azerbaijan, no. 12058/21
Inadequate medical treatment provided to a former Prosecutor General and former Ambassador for his illnesses while in detention during the period between his arrest and his first transfer to a prison medical facility.
Judgment
Medvid v. Ukraine, no. 7453/23
Clear and realistic prospect of reducibility of life sentences after – but not before – new release on parole mechanism became fully operational.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Namık Yüksel v. Türkiye, no. 28791/10
Restrictions imposed on applicant’s contact with four-year-old son staying with his wife in the same prison.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Sahraoui and Others v. France, no. 35402/20
Death in prison of a drug-addicted prisoner as a result of intoxication by prescribed and non-prescribed drugs.
Judgment | Legal Summary
W.W. v. Poland, no. 31842/20
Refusal to allow transgender person to continue prescribed hormone therapy after transfer in new prison.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Spišák v. the Czech Republic, no. 13968/22
Article 14 in conjunction with Article 5: longer period of automatic judicial review of pre-trial detention for minors than for adults prosecuted for the same category of offence.
Judgment
D v. Latvia, no. 76680/17
Segregation, restricted access to basic prison resources and denial of human contact of a prisoner by fellow inmates due to subordinate position in informal prisoner hierarchy.
Judgment | Legal Summary
İlerde and Others v. Türkiye, nos. 35614/19 and 10 others
Exclusion of outdoor yards attached to cells in the calculation of prisoners' personal living space.
Judgment
Schmidt and Šmigol v. Estonia, nos. 3501/20 and 2 others
Consecutive enforcement of disciplinary punishments and security measures in prison resulting in protracted periods of solitary confinement.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Vukušić v. Croatia, no. 37522/16
Prolonged placement of a prisoner, without clothing, in a specially secured padded cell and with lights continuously on.
Judgment
Stott v. the United Kingdom, no. 26104/19
Difference in treatment in early release eligibility between prisoners serving an extended determinate prison sentence vis-à-vis standard determinate sentence prisoners and discretionary life sentence prisoners.
Judgment
El-Asmar v. Denmark, no. 27753/19
Use of pepper spray against a prisoner in an observation cell without prior warning.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Osman and Altay v. Türkiye, nos. 23782/20 and 40731/20
Withholding by prison authorities of issues of a periodical sent to prisoners by post without going through administration as required by law.
Judgment | Legal Summary
S.P. and Others v. Russia, nos 36463/11 and 10 others
Segregation, humiliation and abuse of prisoners by fellow inmates on account of inferior status in informal prisoner hierarchy tolerated by prison staff.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Deltuva v. Lithuania, no. 38144/20
Restriction on family visits with wife and daughter during pre-trial detention.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Machina v. the Republic of Moldova, no. 69086/14
Alleged infection in prison with a transmissible disease.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Yakovlyev v. Ukraine, no. 42010/18
Force-feeding of prisoner on hunger strike in protest against prison treatment.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Kalda v. Estonia (no. 2), no. 14581/20
Blanket ban on prisoners’ voting.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Subaşı and Others v. Türkiye, nos. 3468/20 and 18 others
Prisoners denied permission to receive visits from their school-age children and to make telephone calls at the weekends.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Kupinskyy v. Ukraine, no. 5084/18
Conversion, upon prisoner’s transfer, of a foreign reducible life sentence into an irreducible one due to unavailability of parole for life prisoners in his home State. Applicability and merits.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Constantin-Lucian Spînu v. Romania, no. 29443/20
Denial of permission for prisoner to attend religious services outside prison during Covid-19 pandemic.
Judgment | Legal Summary
P.C. v. Ireland, no. 26922/19
Convicted prisoner statutorily disqualified from old-age pension payments while incarcerated. Applicability and merits.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Chocholáč v. Slovakia, no. 81292/17
General and indiscriminate ban on prisoner possession of pornographic material.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Abdullah Yalçın v. Turkey (no. 2), no. 34417/10
Refusal to allocate room in high-security prison to Muslim prisoner for congregational Friday prayers. Applicability and merits.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Volodya Avetisyan v. Armenia, no. 39087/15
Domestic remedies for complaints as to inadequate conditions of detention.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Maslák v. Slovakia (no. 2), no. 38321/17
Placement of detainee in high security unit and decision-making process.
Judgment
Laniauskas v. Lithuania, no. 48309/19
Continued detention of visually impaired convicted prisoner.
Judgment
Nuh Uzun and Others v. Turkey, nos. 49341/18 and 13 others
The uploading of prisoners’ correspondence to a judicial IT server.
Judgment
Vool and Toomik v. Estonia, nos. 7613/18 and 12222/18
Impossibility of remand prisoners to receive conjugal visits.
Judgment
Zayidov v. Azerbaijan (no. 2), no. 5386/10
Confiscation and destruction of a book manuscript written by a journalist in detention.
Judgment
Cosovan v. the Republic of Moldova, no. 13472/18
Detention extended despite terminal condition.
Judgment
Normantowicz v. Poland, no. 65196/16
Special-needs prisoner's medical care and length of the examination of his request for a licence for prison leave on health grounds.
Judgment
Fenech v. Malta, no. 19090/20
Conditions of detention amid Covid-19 pandemic. Solitary confinement on medical grounds.
Judgment | Legal Summary
Shirkhanyan v. Armenia, no. 54547/16
Detainee not allowed to have private meetings with his representatives before the Court for a prolonged period of time. Alleged technical issue concerning Rule 39: hinder the exercise.
Judgment
